He's getting paid to make baseball decisions!!  

Posted

Bottom of the 7th, cubs are up 3-1. Guy on first, one out. Maddux up.

Clearly, you pinch hit for greg maddux.

Dusty Baker let's him hit. Actually, he let's him bunt.

Now, Baker is retarded, so i can't expect him to actually grasp the concept that even if you are just looking for one run, the best way to get it is to not play small ball.

but, after maddux fails to move the runner over (guy out at second), he doesn't even pinch run for greg.

If you are going to pull your pitcher (which he after the inning), why have him out there running? he's 1) slow and 2) it's a risk of injury.

And why even have maddux doing the bunting for that matter. even if maddux is the best bunting option, what happens if it goes to two strikes? now you have maddux up there having to (attempt to) hit.

I hate dusty baker.

my hard work on friday  

Posted

Dennis (newark): I was at your fight against oquendo and I thought you did a great job. However, when i saw the replay on tv, the announcers were bashing the decision. Why do you think they claimed that?

Chris Byrd: (4:24 PM ET ) I don't know what their problem is. They don't like me. I thought I won too. I got the decision, so it doesn't matter.

-----------

Dennis (newark): and i won 40 bucks from my friend on that fight...so, if you are ever in brick city, feel free to pick up your end :)

Chris Byrd: (4:27 PM ET ) Dennis, I want it all in nickels!

----------

[this was after he said his favorite meal was hot wings]

Bleu Cheese Dipping Sauce: Hey, where's the love?

Chris Byrd: (4:32 PM ET ) Oh yeah, my bad. All of it, and don't forget the celery and carrots!

------

[this was after he said he didn't like chris rock]

Dave Chapelle: Do you like me at least?

Chris Byrd: (4:34 PM ET ) Oh yeah. Dave Chapelle, you're the man dawg!

-----

Adam (redbank): If you could get through a fight with little to no effort (say 3rd round knockout, no injuries on your part), how quickly could you turn around and fight again?

Chris Byrd: (4:42 PM ET ) Realistically? A week later.

Chris Byrd: (4:42 PM ET ) Schedule wise ... six weeks.

------

Elaine (San Diego): Are you saddened by the fact that retired boxers can't stay retired? Why can't they just let go? Money, ego, both?

Chris Byrd: (4:45 PM ET ) Everything. I agree with you Elaine. Stay retired. That's why they call it retirement.

---------

[and this one was for rob neyer]

Spelling Police: That's twice already you made fun of someone for a spelling mistake. At least they can say the names without a huge lisp.

Rob Neyer: (11:28 AM ET ) Actually, the first time was for a grammar mistake. And if my lisp is so huge, then how come I'm on TV and you're not?

A hitter "relief ace"  

Posted

ok, as my head was swirling over counters to steve's ridiculous claims (and believe me, that rant will come later) i think i actually came up with a theory that's worthy of primate discussion.

I was thinking about the relief ace, and how one of the few ways a manager can tip the w/l balance in his favor is by proper relief pitcher usage. Well, why doesn't this work for hitting? Namely, with the greatest hitter of all time, Barry Bonds. I think there is a way to maximize his value on an otherwise anemic offense.

First, you have to determine what the optimum amount of playing time is for Barry. CW thinks that an occassional day off will optimize Barry's performance, on many levels in including mental and physical fatigue, general endurance, and risk of injury. For sake of simplicity, say it comes out to 20 games off a season.

Now, those 20 games need to be spread out. I imagine that there are three levels of fatigue for a player like bonds. 1) I'm ready to go skip 2) I can play if you need me, but a day off would be useful and 3) i'm tired, i need a day off. Clearly, you would never rest him at 1, always rest him at 3, and then try to figure out the best times to rest him at 2.

I think CW is making their biggest mistake in how they utilize rest in the 2 zone. I assume that rest in certain situations (after an extra inning game, day game after a night game, etc) is more valuable. Similarly, it's possible that there is a stress that comes with playing in a game that can't be turned off once it's turned on. In other words, playing two games in a row, even if you are removed halfway through, might be more mentally fatiguing than playing one full game and then having a full day's rest. I don't KNOW that this is true, in fact i think it's not true, but it's possible. However, for the purposes of this theory, i'm going to ignore this unmeasurable level of mental stress.

Ok, so getting back to how to use the 20 games off most efficiently. The first thing you have to do is stop looking at is as 20 games. Instead, see it is 180 innings. If you need to rest bonds for 180 innings, what innings would you pick? Obviously the end of blowouts are where you'd pull him for a replacement (and even CW sees this). But what about the BEGINNING of blowouts. Ah, if only we could look back and figure out how to do that. And there's the rub.

Once Bonds gets into the "2 zone" he should be starting the game on the bench. If the game becomes a blowout

(the term blowout can be defined as loosely as a difference of more than 4 runs. Yes, there will be times where a lead of that size can be overcome, but we are trying to maximize the value of bonds' innings and those percentages of "coming back" are rather low)

then bonds can sit the whole game and get his full rest. However, it's likely that the game will not be a blowout. In those cases, you bring Bonds in whenever he has the greatest likelyhood to have the most impact. At some point in the game, one of the Giants' outfielders is going to come up in an "important" situation (bases loaded, 1 out or maybe first and 2nd with 2 outs) That's when you pinch hit Bonds. I don't care if it's the 8th inning or even the 3rd. At that moment, Bonds is going to have a chance to seriously affect the outcome of the game. In a normal, 4 at bat game, Bonds might have 3 baserunners in front of him. I would have to look at the data to get an accurate number, and i'm too lazy. However, if you start him on the bench and wait for the perfect time, you are GUARANTEEING that he will come up in a "rbi situation". If the Giants spread out their outfielders in the lineup, it's very likely that there will be at least one situation like this. If Bonds breaks the game open, you could even then pull him again. If he gets out, you now at least have bonds in the lineup of a close game.

Critics of this new theory will argue that you want bonds in as much as possible. They are missing the fact that Bonds will be playing the same number of innings that he would be in a CW setting. As soon as he gets to "zone 1" you play him non stop. But when he's in zone 2, you'll be getting maximum output from him. CW would have you pick random games to sit him. But what if you pick a game to play him that winds up being 7-0 in your favor by the 3rd inning. Poor choice. Or what about the games where he comes up four times with nobody on base. a "perfect" performance only equates to 4 runs. Bonds will have played 9 innings and only had the potential to create 4 runs. However, in that exact same game, imagine that tucker, batting 7th, came up in 6th inning with the bases loaded. That one at bat has a potential of 4 runs. If you pinch hit Bonds there, he's already matched the original hypo but did so using only 1/9 th of the energy. If he fails, you still have bonds in the lineup of a close game.

There are times when a guy gets a day off but is asked to pinch hit in the 9th. that's "good", but not "great". If he fails, then you can look back at that 2-1 game and think "oh man, maybe one more at bat by Bonds would have put us over the top". It's currently unheard of to pinch hit early in a game, but why not? Pinch hitting bonds in the 5th inning with the bases loaded may have cost you one at bat, but it's saved you 5 innings and plus you are guaranteeing an RBI situation. Plus, you are GUARANTEEING that you will never waste a bonds inning in a "blowout". bonds would only come in if the game was still in doubt and would leave as soon as it isn't.

I really don't see a downside to this usage of bonds. In zone 2, bonds needs rest. If you wind up not playing bonds two or three games in a row b/c the situation never presented itself, then he'll eventually get back to zone 1 in which case you play him. If there's a string of 10 games where he winds up pinch hitting in the third inning b/c the situation called for it, so be it. Eventually things will even out OR at the very least he gets to zone 3 and you sit him for a game. While this is going on, there will be a vast increase in RBI opportunities and his production will go up.

This usage essentially creates the hitters equivlant of the relief-ace. You are putting yourself and your team in a situation where you best hitter has the best/most opportunities to do the things required to win, i.e. creating runs.

fin.

I want to fine tune this theory (or at least the writing) so when the opportunity presents itself, i can present it to primer. I think at the very least it would spur some discussion.

so tuna thinks dunn hasn't been good this year.  

Posted

Take a look at sportsline's retarded prediction for adam dunn:

It's safe to say that pitchers have figured out how to work Dunn, who has batted a measly .205 since the 2002 All-Star break. He's a selective hitter who knows how to draw a walk, but it's more a result of his being more apt to take a pitch than being able to identify his pitch. Dunn seems like he's swinging entirely defensively, and pitchers are exploiting that weakness, as evidenced by his high strikeout totals. He should be fully healed from a thumb injury that cost him the final six weeks of last season, but needs to display more aggressiveness in the spring before being expected to break out offensively. Dunn has the talent to rack up huge stat totals if he makes the necessary improvements, but right now expect him to be a real drain on your batting average.

in many ways, dunn is the mascot of our team. everyone focused on his low average last year. Yeah it was bad, but guess what, average is the one stat that flucuates the most over the career path of a hitter and it is also very poor at predicting future sucess. call me crazy, but the fact that he had 27 home runs at the age of 23 (roughly) says he knows something about selecting "his pitch". And, the high strike out rate is the exact OPPOSITE of being defensive in your approach. Too often, batters are so afraid of striking out that they choke up with two strikes and just try and make contact. That often results in lazy grounders. Adam Dunn is NOT like that. He controls the strike zone, and takes and rakes.

As for Tuna saying Dunn hasn't been good this year, he must be looking at different stats.

.333/.484/.875 before today (so add 2/2 with 2 runs, a homer, and 2 walks). He's obviously playing above his head, but there's no reason to believe he wont be a stud this season.

Tuna and adam should start an anti-dunn fan club. People like me pj and steve will ride him like the fantasy stud that he is.

Ratings vs. Quality  

Posted

First, let me get these two gems out of the way:

23 questions: http://proxy.espn.go.com/chat/chatESPN?event_id=5097

5 questions: http://proxy.espn.go.com/chat/chatESPN?event_id=5094

Now, for the purpose of this rant...That Cowherd guy was completely missing my point in terms of the "dumbing down" of sportscenter. Here are a few things that I will concede: 1) ratings for sportscenter is up, 2) more ratings = more immediate revenue with advertisers 3) more people currently like this new style over the style that i like.

Ok, but here are my theories.

First and foremost, there is an unfulfilled demand for a real sports show. Although a minority, the "hardcore sports fan" exist, and are fanatical about their hobby. Create a good show, and you'll have a cult following.

As with all cults, this audience would be loyal and long term. Thus, any decrease in current fan base would be offset by long term stability. The problem with the current SC (as with all fads) is that eventually the fair weather fans will move on. Who wants to be a millionaire, wrestling, etc etc. As high as these shows became, they tumbled down equally quick b/c the fans were just trendy.

Does espn really think that people are going to continue to tune in to hear the new catchphrase of the week? At some point, this is going to get stale and the viewers will tune out. Without your core fan base (who will have now moved onto the internet for sports news), espn will be at square one.

In all forms of media, the second you start altering your product to increase public appeal, you are doomed. It's the classic case of the tail wagging the dog. If something is "good" people will find it. But eventually, things meant to be popular will lose it's audience. Pop songs come in strong and fade. Good music is timeless.

I don't think people are fully aware as to how bad sportscenter is. I spend at least 5 hours a day "learning" about sports. and at no point do i feel a need to put on espn, the channel that's DEDICATED to sports. It's not a sports channel anymore. It's MTV, but without the genius that is real world.

Snake Eyes and Back to the Future III  

Posted

i was flipping between these medicore movies the other night. They were both very annoying.

Snake eyes opens with a long long "scene" where "everything happens." It's so obviously a gimmick as the director is attempting to throw everything out there in an overwhelming fashion. Then, the rest of the movie is meant to piece everything together. I didn't notice if they never cut away from the camera. if they did, i'll give props to the actors for goign through 15 minutes w/o breaking. but i doubt they did that.

everything else about the scene was just terrible. I don't understand how nicholas cage is considered a good actor. he's terrible in this (and con air). His character is so over the top annoying / obnoxious that it's actually painful to watch this scene. I'll never understand why movies/shows go out of their way to make annoying characters. SNL is the absolute worst at this. there are times where, even though i'm not even watching the show, i will have to put the tv on mute because i can't stomache the sound coming out of the actors. painful.

so we get about 15 minutes of cage playing "obnoxious" way over the top. we could have gotten the point in 2 minutes, but whatever. The rest of the movie, the "plot" if you will, is so unrealistic. A girl is walkign around in a white dress COVERED IN BLOOD and nobody notices. Cage figures out the fight is fixed b/c the guy goes down on a phantom punch (how could nobody else notice this? why didn't the guy just lean in and get hit by the punch?)

The ending is really disgusting though. Girl is locked in a room, cage is going to unlock her, bad guy is following cage to find out where girl is. now, i'll need to look this up, but somehow the door magically changed right at the end, so the bad guy had to try and convince the girl to unlock the door herself. uh, i THOUGHT she was locked in there. Then, apparently, there was another door in this little room of hers that led to the outside. again, if such a door existed, why didn't she just leave? are you telling me that a door that connects the outside world to a casino/arena is going to be locked from the inside?

and THEN, at the perfect moment, a big round metal globe crashes into a truck that crashes into the wall and allows the girl to escape. and somehow, the guys in the truck (cops or emergency workers, i can't remember), KNOW that the bad guy (who was a decorated good guy and leading the investigation), was actually bad and that the girl was good. yeah, b/c i know that if i came onto a scene where the lead investigator is chasing after a random girl, and he has a gun pointed at her and saying "freeze", that the guy is really bad and secretly working to sabatage the investigation. ugh. you have to just accept EVERYTHING this movie throws at you, b/c if you start questioning ANYTHING it all falls apart. Did vince russo direct this?

and as for Back to the future III, i've had this problem for years, but i'll rerant. 1950's emmit brown sends marty into old west to save himself (emmit) from being shot. now, the emmit that was in the old west was the one who left from 1985 who himself was obviously the older version of 1950's emmit. got that?

emmmit lives in the 50's, lives until 1985 and then gets sent back to old west. well, if marty goes back to 1950's and explains to emmit what is going down, then everything should change. this trilogy is ENTIRELY about the space time continumum and how things shouldn't be messed up. But, as soon as 1950's emmit learns of his fate in teh old west, that knowledge should have stayed with him until the 1980's and then gone back with him until the old west. Litterally, just by telling him hte info in 1950, all danger could have been averted.

Not only does that point get screwed up, but when emmit finds marty in the old west he 1) wasn't expecting him and 2) doesn't remember dressing him up in that weird cowboy outfit.

my head hurts.

preventing a double play by getting into one  

Posted

yanks up 3-1 bottom of the 8th. 2nd and 3rd, 1 out (posada, matsui). on a 3-2 count (sierra), they sent the runners. Strike em out, throw em out.

they sent the runners so they wouldn't hit into the double player (kay said it so it must be true).

isn't the chance that the hitter is going to strike out greater than the chance that he hits a ball would be a double play w/o motion, but isn't a double play if they are in motion?

if that's the case, then this was stupid.

posada is going to score on a single. a 3 run lead is GAME OVER with mo coming in. there's no difference between a 3 run and a 4 run lead.

there is nothing to be gained, and everything to be lost. and it was.

I'm moving to canada  

Posted

[flash back to 3 weeks ago. we're watching sopranos, and aidriana is describing the family tree to the feds. complicated stuff, but it all "makes sense"]

steve: "you know, if this was the wwe, they would just be making up stuff that goes completely against history."

well, netcop noticed something odd a month or so ago. Chris Benoit, hero to canadians, was now being introduced as "currently residing in atlanta georgia".

as of this monday, everything has been rewritten. All the major faces (benoit, jericho, kim gail, etc etc) that are from canada are now suddenly from the united states. And the heels, like le reistence and christian are from canada. The funny thing is that a few months ago, they started saying christian was from florida as a way to turn him heel (b/c he was partners with face canadian jericho). But, now that they changed all these rules, he's somehow migrated back to canada.

Can you believe this? These are real people, with real families and whatnot. candians are rabid about their wrestling and take great pride in their hometown heros. But the wwe doesn't care. they don't want their faces to be non american. disgusting.

somewhere, tuna is smiling.

I don't get this commercial  

Posted

father and son are outside playing basketball. Both are wearing cleveland cavs jerseys. The father dominates on a possession, makes the basket, and then calls the foul. oh, i should mention the kid is about 5. Then as he's shooting the foul shot (and talking trash), the bottom of the screen says: Without sports, how would we close the gap?

I don't get it. what gap is being closed exactly? This seems like something i should "get", but i don't.

The image i'm getting is obviously that the father is living out a fantasy in the game and that clearly it's ridiculous that he would challenge his son. But wouldn't closing the gap somehow imply that the son is overtaking his dad and the torch is being passed. The cliche is of the kid finally being able to beat his dad for the first time. It's supposed to be both a great and sad moment. but that's not what this scene is.

I know tuna is going to post a one line response where he mocks me for not knowing. Of course, everytime he types something here, he never gets the story straight, so i doubt he's going to be of any help.

The only thing i can think of is that we are supposed to extrapolate the future in our minds and know that at some point the son will surpass the father and close the gap. I mean, the father is already overweight and breathing heavy from just one play. But that's asking too much of the viewer. Commercials, by definition, are a quick image that is meant to capture something. Nobody has the time or effort to think about what they are seeing and then extend it to a future. If you want to close the gap, just have a 14 year old beating his father with a ridiculous shot to end the game. Kid's going nuts, father appears happy on the surface, but deep down you can tell he's upset by the loss. Maybe father then claims that the kid traveled or something. Viewers all know that the kid really won, and closed the gap. Flash the text, and there you go.

What am i misssing?

u know what i can't stand?  

Posted

people who write "u" instead of "you". I could ALM0ST accept it if the person was a terrible typer. But some people (let's keep her identity secret and just call her the greek potato) will write out full sentences where everything is perfect EXCEPT for the U. I can't stand looking at these emails, the u's actually make me sick. I don't get it. Why not just type out the two extra letters. how much effort are you saving? if you want to write everything in short hand, feel free. But if an email has words that are more than 7 letters long, you should never ever write U. that's my rule. stick to it.

Homicide: Life on the Street  

Posted

I've delayed watching my Homicide dvds because i only have 3 episodes left. But, the one i watched tonight was THE episode that got me hooked on the show. I distinctly remember flipping through and being drawn by this powerful scene. I didn't know anything about the characters involved, but the scene was strong enough to stand on its own....

Edit: Eh, i had to delete my summary of the scene. I'm not doing it justice. If you are reading this, just ask to borrow my dvds. It was hands down the greatest drama on network tv (and probably second only to sopranos).

Say What? 4/4/04  

Posted

Last year I used to get so mad at joe morgan and the rest of baseball's "experts" who utter complete nonsense. This year, i'm going to try and paste the choice quotes here for everyone's enjoyment. shall we begin?

joe morgan - "Javy Lopez should benefit from playing here, because this [camden yards] is a park that really favors hitters."

(baseball prospectus has this to say about camden yards: "extreme pitchers park")

John Kruk - "Erstad is superior to Mientkiewicz (sp) offensively"

John Kruk - "Gary Sheffield is the most feared hitter in baseball"

John Kruk (i think we have a pattern forming here): Vlad is the most talented baseball in the game and because of that garrett anderson is going to win the mvp

Jim Caple: AL East Winner: Blue Jays, WC: Angels (yes, he is saying that neither the redsox nor the yanks even make the playoffs!)

Kruk: NL mvp: Giles, NL cy young: wagner.

PJ imagined this conversation taking place:

Joe: You know, camden yards is a real hitters park.

PJ: actually joe, camden yards consistently depresses hitting by about 10%

Joe: I don't care!

[this hypo doesn't play well typed out, but hearing pj have a conversation with himself was priceless]

why do they hate their job again?  

Posted

i'm watching the old real world, and i can't figure out why they hate their job so much. is it b/c it's a job? they complain that their boss treats them like little kids, but i think that's b/c they never show up on time. What do they expect?

we win. maria owes us an apology.  

Posted

there was a segment on sportscenter tonight about the two best female basketball teams in the nation, duke and tenn. "how do these teams get better? by playing men." Both teams have a "practice team" consisting of random guys from their college. Not real basketball players. just college guys. these guys DESTROY the girls teams in practice. the best female players in college were quoted as saying "they are so much better than us, we can't do anything against them"

so, pj's theory is proven true.

VOWW (fantasy's version of Vorp)  

Posted

PJ's down on our team, but I think it looks good.

13 teams play 4 corner infielders each (split obviously between 2 1st and 2 3rd, but combined here for simplicity). That means there are 52 corner infielders starting, and (ignoring bench), that would put the waiver wire guy at 53.

An average team would have these corner outfielders: 25, 26, 27, 28.

Our corner infielders are: 5, 18, 24, 27.

Our middle infielders (instead of the average 24, 25, 26, 27) are:

19, 23, 26, 31. (there's a player or two who is both a CI and MI so i tried to count them once)

Average catchers are 13, 14.

Ours are: 6, 12.

5x13 Outfielders = 65 playing.

Average is: 31, 32, 33, 34, 35.

Ours: 1, 6, 7, 32, 43

Now, this math is oversimplified b/c the talent pool is not bell curve, but pyramid. Thus, it's better to have the ends of the spectrum (a stud and a scrub are better than two average players.) But I don't have time to get into all of That. Besides, if that's the issue, then our Pitching is really going to do some damage. Let's assume that teams are going 6/2 for SP RP.

That puts the average pitchers at:

6x13 = 78

37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42

Ours? 2, 12, 15, 26, 32, 33

Closers (again, assuming 2)

Average: 13, 14.

Ours: 3, 4.

to sum: I like our chances.

Light Thinks!  

Posted

The double slit experiment –

Picture three playing cards standing up like dominoes. The first card has one hole in it. The second card has two holes in it. The third card has no holes in it. As the light comes out of the 2 holes they interact with each other in a process called “diffraction”. Imagine throwing stones into the water. Some of the waves that form will cancel each other out (the dark patches), while other waves will combine to form bigger waves (bright patches). These patches of light and dark land on the last card and is called “interference”.

This interference obviously indicates that light is acting like a wave and not a particle. If light acted like a particle, you’d expect big blobs of light behind the two holes. Imagine throwing darts through the holes.

Electrons shot out will form an interference pattern, but each individual one creates a point like a particle. So, electrons travel like waves, but land as particles. Light, electrons, and all other quantum particles thus act as both waves and particles.

Here’s where the things get crazy: If you shoot out electrons one at a time, the interference pattern still forms. That means 2 things. 1) Each electron must be passing through both holes at the same time AND 2) a single electron is then interacting with itself to create the wave (and interference). Remember, the patches are based on waves interacting with each other. But how can a single electron interact with itself?

Furthermore, shooting them out one at a time still creates the same overall pattern. That means that they “know” where their fellow particles have landed and continue the pattern accordingly. Shooting a million out at the same time will create the exact same pattern as shooting a million separate shots. But how do they “Know”???

Now, when you set up a detector at card 2 to see which hole a particle of light (or electron) is going through, everything changes. Instead of going through both holes and interacting with itself to form an interference pattern, all of a sudden they start acting like particles (darts) and 1) go through only one hole and 2) thus just form 2 blobs of light on card 3. They know they are being watched! Their behavior changes based on being observed.

The second you turn the detector off, they go back to acting “weird”.

So, they then created a “delayed choice” experiment. Instead of detecting the light at the holes in card two, they wanted to look at it half way between card 2 and card 3. Obviously, by this point, the light has passed through card 2 (either through one hole {particle/blob}, or both holes {wave/interference}).

When the detector is on (in mid flight mind you), the light lands as blobs (indicating that they passed as particles. But, if the detector is turned off, they form an interference pattern. So, the decision of whether or not to look at the light at this moment somehow affects how the light acted BEFORE it got to this moment. Past, present, time, causation??? Throw it all out of the window, it no longer exists.

We are only talking about billionths of a second here, but in theory, this should work for anything. There’s something called gravitational lensing. In short, as light travels through galaxies it can be bent by extreme gravitational forces. It’s similar to having the two cards out there in space, galaxies apart. If we decide to observe the light now, it should change to acting like a particle. Not just change now, but go back into time (before our solar system was even formed) and change then. How can what we do now affect a decision that was made billions of years ago?

Top of the Mountain, Bottom of the Valley  

Posted

On monday, I had what may have been the finest moment of my law school career (which in and of itself is a sad commentary on how pathetic my career has been)

In professional responsibility (which is an ethics class), the professor was talking about a life experience. The short version is that when he was a new lawyer, his friend came to him covered in blood and in hysterics. The Prof was able to calm the guy down and call the cops to turn himself in. The cops, in their infinite wisdom, brought the prof in as well and wouldn't let him leave. They demanded that the prof tell them certain information about when the guy came to see him. The professor wasn't sure if he was ethically allowed to divulge certain information (for the non lawyers reading this, just think of "attorney-client privlidge" and you get the BASIC idea).

The professor then began stroking his ego talking about how conflicted he was in his decision making process and how he was balancing all types of issues of ethics and morals. Then, the cops came back and threatened to ruin his career ("how do you think RU Law will react to hearing that one of their profs is being detained as a material witness for a murder?"). So, after a long episode of crying like a baby, the Professor came up with a deal. "if i show you where the knife is, will you let me go?".

Now, whether or not it is "wrong" to show the cops where the knife is is open for debate. Legally, it's a gray area in terms of rules of confidentiality. Similarly, it is reasonable for a person to conclude that the heinessness of murder superseeds (sp) the loyalty you show a friend. But, and here is the important part, the professor didn't make his decision based on either of these two factors. The thing that 100% controlled his decision is how his disclosure would affect him personally.

He asked for comments regarding his decision and someone a few rows in front of me praised him for making the right decision. "you did exactly what i would have done, and you did it for the right reasons." This actually caused me to lift my head up from under my computer and before i knew it, i had my hand up.

"um, getting back to your example professor, if the cops had let you go, would you have still volunteered the location of the knife?"

"no, i wouldn't have.".

"so the way i see it, and correct me if i'm wrong, but it seems like your decision was based entirely on the fact that you had something personally at stake. You only decided to disclose the knife after they threatened your career. You can talk about valor all you want, but that sounds pretty selfish and self serving to me and I don't see how that's 'ethical'".

"well, yeah, i guess you are right, but like i was telling you, i had a little birdie on my shoulder of my old professor who was going over the legal obligations and whether or not i had to disclose the information...."

"yeah, i understand all that, but like you said, you didn't make your decision based on that issue. You said you turned over the knife b/c of their threats, and if those threats didn't exist, you wouldn't have turned over the knife. So, your decision was based on personal gains."

"well, maybe i would have felt the guilty the next morning and gone back to them and turned in teh knife."

"ok. fine."

as i was done getting off my high horse, dan goes "i can't believe you just did that."

during the break 2 people came up to me and said "are you the one who called out the professor for being a hypocrite? way to go!"

the next day, another person came up to me and was all excited by my comments.

And thus, I have started the revolution. It only took 2 years and 10 months.

I'll right the valley part of the blog tomm. i'm tired and busy.

two types of commercials that need to stop  

Posted

1) the split screen NCAA commercials where the jocks claim to be something more than jocks. We don't care. Move on. It was worse last year, with that stupid swimmer's commerical that played EVERY break between games in the first two rounds.

2) commercials, in general, that make "music" with something other than instruments. McDonalds did it back in the day. Pringles had a nice run. Now there's a banging on the car commercial. We get it. It's over.

things i need to rant on  

Posted

curb, apprentice, failed suicide attempt, night terrors, other convos, elimindate, liberal comedy, poker tables, and such and such.

i'm just too tired. i know i've already forgotten the good ones.

Dogs exhibiting good ring psychology  

Posted

I had forgotten this story, but steve reminded me, so here we go.....

Before they moved in, we went to check out their apartment (it's 2 blocks from my house). As we were walking (they refused to carry me), we get blindsided by the most ferocious dog that Newark has to offer. This thing was behind a fence, but i was scared enough to jump backward when it started barking.

Having none of what he was offering, we decided to cross the street to avoid this demon. Well, just as we get to the other side, we are "pearl harbored" by a dog that was twice the size (and three times the "evil") of the one across the street. This reincarnation of hitler didn't get excited, per se, when it saw us. It was almost as though it was expecting us and snuck up to the gate to get the perfect angle of attack.

As I ran in horror, i turned my head and i SWEAR i saw the two dogs head nod to each other. We were apparently the victims of a diabolical plan developed by the two dogs. Well played, canines, well played.

[i swore that day that i would never walk to their house again, or at the very least, i would take the long route. i don't know whatever happened to those dogs though, b/c they aren't there anymore. perhaps they took their show on the road]